"Fast feet"
"Get those feet moving"
"Bubble, Bubbles! My grandma could kick faster...and she's been dead for 20 years!"
These expletives are thrown around the pool deck more than a kickboard slicing through the air like a Frisbee. In swimming fast feet are associated with fast swimming, however fast hands don't always correlate with fast swimming.
In regards to the upper body, distance per stroke and obtaining a long reach desired for stroke efficiency and energy conservation, but distance per kick and kicking efficency are never (I don't say never often) discussed upon the pool deck. Think about it, if a swimmer can go as fast with less kicks, won't they save energy and become more efficient?
Kicking is essential for optimal swimming. More and more elite teams are putting higher volumes of kicking into their programs. This volume directly improves many swimmers, but every coach knows swimmers whom never become adequate kickers despite countless yards and frustrations while being lapped in practice by an all-star 12-year old girl with a huge magnum, bobble head.
I have worked with many swimmers who die at the end of their races. Fatigue is a multi-variable resultant seen at the end of a race. During every optimal movement screen I have the athlete perform specific movements looking for overactive, weak, long, and short muscles, but first of all I ask the swimmer where they feel they fatigue with the arms or upper body being the most common response. In my opinion, simply asking swimmers or knowing where the athlete fatigues is essential for improvement as are only as strong as our weakest link.
Poor Conditioning?
Arm fatigue is experienced by many swimmers at the end of all their races and most of the swimming society purely chalks it up to poor conditioning. Poor conditioning may be the cause, but from my experience, simply using more yards or improving arm strength does not improve the situation. Poor conditioning isn't always the answer! The more you put in doesn't necessarily make it correct! The person with their turn signal on for 15 miles isn't the most likely person to turn! The swimming community needs to make theories and hypotheses on how to improve a subject/problem once a strong background is obtained on the subject.
Athlete's to Blame?
Our sport constantly puts blame on the swimmers chalking poor conditioning or inefficient feel without attempting to find a solution to these problems. In my opinion, everything has a solution. The solution isn't the same for everyone and sometimes the rationale behind the answer is poor or inadequate, but an answer for everything is out there, but if you don't try you'll never find it!
Leg Lock
Now it is time to connect the dots between upper extremity fatigue and distance per kick. Too many coaches have tunnel vision, simply providing viewing a problem has a simple one variable algebraic equation. In my opinion, upper extremity fatigue in elite swimmers starts in two places: inefficient breathing/jaw relaxation and/or poor kicking efficiency, preventing axial hip rotation and more stress put on the upper body. These indirect hypotheses require deductive reasoning and an understanding of the connective chain, lets discuss how fast feet contribute to Fred Flinstone arms.
LLNFG
LLNFG is a horrible acronym to remember the Groin Kick Syndrome, but focus on the process rather than the name!
Leg Spin-->Leg Lock-->No Ro(toation)-->Fred Flintstone arms-->Groin Kick Syndrome (GKS)
- Leg Spin: Many swimmers are conditioned at the end of a race to increase their kicking speed. This causes swimmers to spin their legs, not adequately allowing a fluid efficient kick. Kicking forward propulsion is controlled by hip flexion and knee extension, similarily to kicking a soccer ball. This motion allows whipping and energy transfer to maximize propulsion. Unfortunately, when the legs spin the fluid soccer like kick is replaced with an inefficient movement. A lack of efficient decreases the kicking economy while using more and more energy. The more energy consumed/used leads to leg lock.
- Leg Lock: The legs contain the largest volume of skeletal muscle in the body. These monstrous areas consume a lot of oxygen and are unfortunately located far away from the lungs. This consumption leads to massive lactic acid build-up and fatigue in the legs locking them up and causing No Ro(toation).
- No Ro: The strongest muscle in kicking is the rectus femoris (one of the quadriceps). This muscle crosses both the hip and knee joint allowing both motions for a fluid kick, hip flexion and knee extension. Once locked the rectus femoris prevents hip mobility. Without proper hip mobility the swimmer is not able to rotate their body properly, to use a hybrid or hip driven stroke. This result is disastrous and causes the athlete to swim like a brick in the water with high frontal drag.

- Fred Flinstone arms: Once the legs are locked the body plows through the water relying on the arms for all forward propulsion. At this time, the arms start to spin, causing fatigue/lactic acid/decreased "feel" and Fred Flinstone arms. As the arms fill with lactic acid the bodies lactate levels rise above 10 mmol and the body enters groin kick syndrome.
- GKS: Every post-pubescent swimmer has experienced GKS. It runs rampant in over-confident or naïve swimmers trying distances longer than their capacity. Once the arms and legs tighten and the bodies lactate sky rockets and the body becomes acidic with a massive pH drop. This poisonous shift is harmful for success and halts many swimmers at the flags as they try to get to just get their damn hand on the wall.
Warp-up
Like I said, every post-pubescent swimmer has experienced GKS and will continue to do so, but if you continually experience GKS and achieve Fred Flinstone arms at the end of the race, maybe adding 1,500 pull at the end of every workout isn't the best answer. Instead look at the beginning of the continuum...leg spin. The next installment of GKS will look at methods to improve distance per kick (DPK) and kicking efficiency.
By Dr. G. John Mullen, DPT, CSCS. He is the founder of the Center of Optimal Restoration and head strength coach at Santa Clara Swim Club.


Great post, very few people have anything to say about kicking technique besides "keep your legs straight and ankles floppy". I've felt "leg lock" before but didn't realize that it results in inhibiting rotation.
ReplyDeleteConversely, my rotation *feels* a stronger connection (hip to arm catch) when I do a set with 0 kicking... lock might be possible even at low speeds with 0 lactate due to poor kicking rhythm...
Do you have a physiological term for "locking up"? Is this when the H+ ion concentration builds up to the the point where contractions are less forceful (so fewer fibers were recruited as muscle fibers follow the all or none principle) so it's a actual energy systems issue, or might it be a "cramping" sensation?
ReplyDeleteJust want to make sure I understand the syndrome correctly.
I used to be a long-distance-swimmer, always taking a beating on the shorter distances from the other guys in my group. But in addition to swimming, I did a whole bunch of bicycling year-round (about 3000miles per year, always cycling to the school/practice), and some stair-climbing in the off-season (usually 3x322 steps per day, for about 30 days every summer, when we didn't have any swim training).
ReplyDeleteThose 2 things pretty much helped me win / be in the top three (in our group) even in the shorter distances, IF we were doing only kicking races. And I claim this was only due to my bicycling / stair climbing, because I never put any effort in my normal kicking sets during normal swim training. And I took a huge beating from just about everyone if we were also using our hands.
When I was 16, I got my patella dislocated (playing football), and I most of my swim training, especially the backstroke training, with only my hands (& pull boyo) for about 4months. You'd really think that would be pretty bad, huh? But at the end of those 4months, I had my personal best in the 200back (mainly kicking with 1 leg), and I could never brake that time again, not even after trying to do it for 2,5years, not even after braking just about every other of my records. When setting that record, I remember feeling like my hands were 'flying', not ehausted at all etc. A feeling that I never got back after I started training 'normal' again.
I feel some swimmers do far too little pulling. After moving to a bigger city, in my new club there is even some guideline that ~20% of the training should be kicking, but there isn't a single rule about pulling, and paddle-use is forbidden (except for the oldest swimmers) !!
Oh and btw, have you ever heard of any studies etc that would indicate that using swimming paddles (let's say for about 10% of your training) with even a remotely good technique would cause the swimmer to have shoulder problems etc ?
ReplyDelete(Because in our swim club we have a ban on them (as I mentioned before, for everyone 'not old', or not in the top2 groups), and it just feels completely ridiculous.)
Pulling with paddles changes your technique (principle of specificity), it's a different skill than pulling unassisted.
ReplyDeletehttp://www-rohan.sdsu.edu/dept/coachsci/swim/ccf/ccf0802.htm
Adding more resistance to the pulling action doesn't necessarily improve your speed. Extra force production (ex, producing 100 instead of 50 newtons of force with each hand) doesn't mean you'll go faster if you're technique doesn't allow you to hold enough water to benefit from the extra force. You might end up "slipping" (as in not catching the water) if you develop additional pulling strength without concurrently modifying your pull technique to accomodate the extra strength.
Paddle study w/10 people (shows form changed):
http://www-rohan.sdsu.edu/dept/coachsci/swim/hydros/toussai1.htm
Paddle study with 105 elite british swimmers indicating shoulder pain
http://www-rohan.sdsu.edu/dept/coachsci/swim/training/pollard.htm
Paddle study showing they make you go faster without working harder
http://www-rohan.sdsu.edu/dept/coachsci/swim/training/ogita.htm
@ qu1ckbadger, in my opinion leg log is the result of lactate in the bloodstream.
ReplyDeleteGreat posts and comments!